When Honesty Isn’t Best


I am a firm believer that honesty is the best policy, except when it isn’t. There are times when what we feel should not be expressed. Let me explain.

Have you ever had a strong connection with someone that you can’t be with? I have a friend, a male friend, and we are only friends. Truth be told, we have a lot in common and if it weren’t for each of us already being married, we may have had a chance together. But the world doesn’t work that way and I would never trade what I have with my husband.

This friend, let’s call him Jake, we used to be able to talk about anything and everything, which was always nice because I have a hard time doing that with most people. We never hung out often but when we ran into each other with friends, it was easy to pick right back up where we last left off. I always felt like he actually liked talking with me and never judged me.

I noticed something in him the first night we met, at his wedding rehearsal dinner of all places.  He and my husband are friends and my husband took me along. I think we first met near a food table and we just started talking, and after a little bit I realized we had been standing there talking for a long time! I am socially awkward but I was able to talk to him so easily. I will say, I left that night with some kind of feeling for him but immediately dismissed it since I was already in a relationship that I was happy with.  I guess I was just left with this strange connection with Jake, like we had always known each other.

Jake got married the next day and over the years that followed, we would run into each other downtown every now again and talk while drinking some beer with mutual friends. Funny thing is, his wife never went out with him and my husband never came out with me. If they had, we may not have gotten so talk much. Both our spouses are pretty suspicious of anything. With mine, it always kind of made me mad because he is friends with all kinds of girls and I think nothing of it, but if I talk to a guy, I can tell my husband’s mind goes in every which direction.  I don’t blame him too much because he was cheated on in the past and so I understand his predisposition to doubt.

Jake and I remained as distant friends. I had some feelings that I ignored and I had no idea what he thought in that aspect. It wasn’t something to be addressed or acted upon anyway; I just appreciated his friendship. With a life full of people judging me, having someone who didn’t was amazing. I could just be myself.

But then, we all got together one night at a friend’s house and we all were there, us and our spouses.  There was lots of drinking. At one point, everyone was inside and I went outside to get an ice cold beer out of the cooler and Jake followed me. He chose that moment to tell me how he felt about me. He said that he just wanted me to know but that he would never act on it because he thinks my husband is an amazing person and friend. I, in my  own drunkeness, told him the same thing. We both agreed that we valued our friendship and would never act on it. And then, my husband comes out to get a beer and apologizes for “interrupting” – well, that’s not good.  And then when we went back inside, Jake’s wife made a snide comment about how long we were talking outside. Damn! There we were, just having a discussion, and yet our spouses were already suspicious and over-reacting. Sure, it was a not-so-innocent discussion but the outcome was that we were going to leave it alone, we were going to do the right thing. People in relationships everywhere find themselves attracted to someone else; it’s human nature after all. The difference is those who act on it and those who value what they already have and don’t.

Here’s the thing – although we were being honest with each other – it never should have been said, never should have been spoken – that is where we did go wrong. And I honestly don’t think it would have been said had we not been drinking. It felt great in the moment, nice to know that someone out there cared, but by the next day, I knew everything had changed. We stayed friends but once his wife somehow read a couple light-hearted emails we had exchanged, all hell broke loose oh his side. We weren’t allowed to be friends anymore. She never said anything to my husband, and truth be told, there wasn’t even anything to tell. Although we had once drunkenly expressed a feeling verbally with each other, we never acted on it. We loved our spouses and unlike so many others, that commitment meant something to us, at least I know it does for me. But, the damage had been done and our friendship suffered.

I miss my friend. Funny how a few beers and some honest words killed a friendship I so adored. We say hello every now and again, but its different. It’s not as easy-going as it once was, before. And I feel like I am trying harder than he is which leaves me feeling like one of “those” girls trying to hold on and this isn’t even a romantic relationship! I guess his friendship just meant more to me than I ever knew and now it is almost non-existent.

Was it worth it, those drunken words? No, it wasn’t. Part of me was glad that I knew but the rest of me is sad for the loss of a valued friendship. I wish I had never told him and that he had never told me. I wish we could go back to before. Honesty, in this case, destroyed something good. It was a line that never should have been crossed.

So why  am I writing about this? Because I think of Jake often, and the friendship we lost. Regret is a terrible thing. Be careful with your words my friends, you never know what you could lose.



19 thoughts on “When Honesty Isn’t Best

  1. Can’t be truer. But same goes for concealing and dishonesty. There will be tonnes of relationship which got broken because of concealment or many relationships which never came to life because there was no expression. It is just about choices. Whatever is going to happen will happen. What if his wife would not have read those emails? You are blaming it all on your honesty towards your friend; rather it shall be all blamed on mistrust between two spouses which has nothing to do between you and your friend’s honesty towards each other. Trust me you did nothing wrong and there is no wrong time to be honest.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I completely see what you are saying here. Honesty can be a fine line sometime. I do believe though that in romantic relationships, attraction to others is something that should not be spoken or expressed. It happens to everyone and just because there is an attraction to someone else, it does not mean that who you are with is the wrong person. Life IS about choices, and I am happy with who I chose to be with. Therefore, expression of attraction to another is not necessary.

      I am curious though, in your response to this post, you say there is never a wrong time to be honest, and yet in responding to another post of mine, you stated that sometimes you NEED to be fake for others. Those two things seem to be in opposition to each other.

      Once again, like you have said before, it is all about balance. No one can be honest all the time; it’s just how humanity is.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. These temptations are thrown in our path now and then. Having the temptation is natural to man, voicing it leads one step closer to acting on it. Life is tricky that way. Drunk makes the situation that much more difficult.
    Friendship is distant for now, but not gone, and something even better has occurred. Both couples are still happily married. This is the best we can expect out of life.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you sweetness. There is such a duality in life sometimes. I have had to give up many people I care about it, including family, all due to life circumstance and widely different and opposing personalities. I guess that’s just life though and that is the reason we need to value and enjoy what we have when we have it.

      Liked by 1 person

  3. This stirs up so many emotions. I ‘ve been in this situation a few times. Did I act on it? Well yes. I can’t hep feeling but I do know what I want and I suppose that is what matters. It does suck that you were honouring your vows but life happens and well at least you know you weren’t alone in how you felt 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

      1. Most good stories begin from the dilemma of incompatible duties, commitments, or desires. The world does not hold together with perfect unity. Every unity has a remainder. Thus: death.

        This also gives value to the unities and harmonies we are able to build, and sustain.

        Liked by 1 person

    1. True, and not feeling alone is nice. I guess we all have our reasons for the lines we cross, good or bad or just real. My thoughts are with you as you have traveled this windy road as well. HUGS to you!


  4. That sucks. The good news: such connections happen multiple times across one’s life, usually — even if they don’t happen often. “Jake’s” wife might cool off, too, which may give the two of you some portion of what you both lost. Don’t hang your only hat on that hope, though — any friendship, now that his wife is suspicious, could make life worse for both of them.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I let go of a lot of the hope a while ago, as the last thing I want to do is create problems for them. I guess true friendships are rare for me so it is difficult to lose one of them.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s